Sell Your Jewelry in Buffalo Now!

Sell Your Jewelry Now

Don't let your jewelry collect dust in your jewelry box. Unlock it's value today with a free-consultion from one our jewelry buying experts.

Book Appointment

Our team of GIA trained appraisers have decades of experience in the second-hand diamond market. We have the experience and reputation to help make your selling experience as enjoyable as your buying experience. With over 500 online 5-star reviews and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, we are confident you’ll feel at ease while in our care. Andrews Jewelers will pay you cash for your gold, help you sell your diamond, buy your Rolex, and more. We are Buffalo's top bidder for your unwanted jewelry.

Meet with an Andrews Jewelers diamond buyer discreetly at our Williamsville office
We’ll inspect your item(s) and make an on-the-spot offer
We can pay instant cash for your valuables
No painful haggling, you’ll receive our up-front offer and professional service

We Buy Jewelry in Buffalo and Pay Fast Cash

Diamonds

We are cash buyers of loose diamonds and set diamonds of 2.00ct and larger. Andrews Jewelers will consider your engagement ring, loose diamond, or wedding rings. Read below to learn how the process works. *We do not purchase lab-grown diamonds.

Scrap gold, broken jewelry, unwanted items

Bring us your unwanted items including gold chains, rings of any kind, wedding bands, old pocket watches, dental gold, broken jewelry and more. We will pay the highest cash price.

Rolex Watches

Andrews Jewelers is Buffalo's top buyer of Rolex watches including ladies and mens Date Just, Submariner, Daytona, and Yachmaster. Nobody will pay you more, and we pay instant cash.

Sterling Silver & Flatware

Andrews Jewelers is a cash buying of old sterling silver flatware, knives, forks, and place settings. We'll evaluate what you have and make a serious offer.

Gold Ingots & Coins

Andrews Jewelers pays top dollar for gold coins in any condition including US Coins, Krugerrands, Sovereigns, Canadian Maple Leafs and more. We’ll also buy your .999 gold ingots and bars in any size from 1ounce, 5 ounce, and 10 ounces bars. Andrews Jewelers will accept small and large quantities.

Silver Ingots & Coins, and Collectables

Bring us your .999 fine silver collectables, silver dollars, silver ingots, and pre-1964 US silver coins. We’ll make you an upfront competitive offer and pay you on the spot. No lot/collection is too big or too small…we can service any customer.

How to Sell Your Scrap Gold & Unwanted Jewelry

Schedule an Appointment

Use our online form to book a convenient time to meet with one of our GIA trained sales professionals at our showroom in Williamsville, NY. You can also speak immediately to a customer service representative using our online chat.

Meet with an Appraiser

You’ll meet privately with an Andrews Jewelers appraiser to evaluate the items you would like to sell. This will be done right in front of you.

Receive a No-Haggle Offer

Unlike other jewelry buyers, we’ll provide a free upfront offer that will be the most we can pay for your items. You’ll never have to wonder if you should have received more, that’s because you’ll get our top-offer.

Instant Payment

If you find our offer acceptable, we’ll pay you on-the-spot with cash or check depending on your choosing. Our aim is to provide a fair and equitable way for you to sell your items, that’s why we will not charge fees or commission

How to Sell Your Diamond or Engagement Ring

Tell Us What You Have

We're looking for diamonds loose or set in engagement rings. The shapes we want are round, oval, and radiant of 2.00ct and larger. Your diamond/ring should have a GIA, IGI, or AGS certification. We are not buying lab grown diamonds.

Prepare for Your Visit

You'll need to decide how much you want to be paid for your diamond or engagement ring. It's important for you to think about what you'll accept prior to your visit, and then express this to our buyers. Andrews Jewelers will not make blind offers on your diamond. Kindly, bring accompanying paperwork such as certifcations, appraisals, or receipts.

Meet with a Diamond Buyer

One of our trained diamond buyers will meet with you and inspect your diamond. They'll examine your paperwork and diamond to determine if your selling price is acceptable. Please inform them of what it is that you would like to receive for your items, if our buyers feel it is a fair price we will accept your offer.

Negotiations & Payment

If our buyers find your selling price to be fair we'll pay you on the spot. In some situations we may inform you that your selling price is more than we can afford. If this is the case, a counter-offer from our diamond buyer is possible. If you find a counter-offer agreeable we'llpay you cash or check on the spot. Appointments are not necessary but can be helpful.