Sell Your Jewelry Now

Selling Your Diamonds, jewelry and Rolex watches to Andrews Jewelers is a Breeze! Established in 1994, Andrews Jewelers has been buying and selling diamonds in WNY for nearly 30 years.

Our team of GIA trained appraisers have decades of experience in the second-hand diamond market. We have the experience and reputation to help make your selling experience as enjoyable as your buying experience. With over 500 online 5-star reviews and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, we are confident you’ll feel at ease while in our care.

Jeweler Working

In-Person Private Evaluation

  • Meet with an Andrews Jewelers diamond buyer discreetly at our Williamsville office
  • We’ll inspect your item(s) and make an on-the-spot offer
  • We can pay instant cash for your valuables
  • No painful haggling, you’ll receive our up-front offer and professional service

What We Buy

Uncertified and certified diamonds of .50ct and larger
Loose Diamonds
Scrap Gold
Scrap gold, broken jewelry, unwanted items
Lorem Ipsum is simply dummy text of the printing and typesetting industry.
Rolex watches
We used our customer's sapphire and designed an amazing platinum diamond engagement setting for it.
Loose Diamonds
GIA certified fancy colored diamonds
Lorem Ipsum is simply dummy text of the printing and typesetting industry.

  1. Staff Member

    Schedule an Appointment

    Use our online form to book a convenient time to meet with one of our GIA trained sales professionals at our showroom in Williamsville, NY. You can also speak immediately to a customer service representative using our online chat.

  2. Appraiser

    Meet with an Appraiser

    You’ll meet privately with an Andrews Jewelers appraiser to evaluate the items you would like to sell. This will be done right in front of you.

  3. Offer

    Receive a No-Haggle Offer

    Unlike other jewelry buyers, we’ll provide a free upfront offer that will be the most we can pay for your items. You’ll never have to wonder if you should have received more, that’s because you’ll get our top-offer.

  4. Check

    Instant Payment

    If you find our offer acceptable, we’ll pay you on-the-spot with cash or check depending on your choosing. Our aim is to provide a fair and equitable way for you to sell your items, that’s why we will not charge fees or commission.

Sell Your Jewelry Now

Book Appointment Live Chat